21 June 2005 @ 01:00 pm
an older fandom...  
I'm getting kind of tired of all the bashing of the FMA anime that goes on. And for once I'm not talking about people on the MU*s but rather people scattered about LJ.

Guys, Bones did not up and decide to ruin a beautiful manga. They got the series when it wasn't very far into the manga, and it was only publishing once per month. They must have known from the start they'd have to split from canon at some point. Did they do a brilliant job of it? Well, no. But they did not set out to ruin your perfect story, nor did they deliberately screw it all up. They were operating under external constraints that forced them into rather less than ideal situations.

You want to see an anime that might as well have deliberately set out to screw things up? Go look at Bleach, its slipshod pacing, its rough insertion of characters in the wrong places, its careless cutting of important moments--when it had plenty to work with in the start.

FMA simply did not have that luxury. It would have been nice if they'd waited to license it until the manga was finished, but as things turned out, that wasn't what happened--so they had to stumble along with their own plot. It was nowhere near as good as it could/should have been, but to a point they did pretty damn well. They fleshed out a bunch of minor characters, captured several scenes beautifully, and in general gave us some excellent moments and a reasonably decent plot for a while.

It may not be the manga, and it may not be what you wanted, and it may not be everybody's cup of tea, but stop acting as if Bones is the Antichrist because they couldn't live up to the manga.
 
 
( 14 made a stand — Post a new comment )
Li[info]trelali on June 21st, 2005 11:11 am (UTC)
The manga's definitely my favorite between the two, but I really enjoyed the anime. There were a few episodes that I really disliked (wtf was up with the episode that centered around Lust, in the midst of an incredibly more important storyline? It was great that they made her a little more 3-D, but come on-- there wasn't a better place to do it?) but overall, I loved it. The Nina-arc always comes to mind when I think of the anime, and I think they did that really beautifully.

/nerd.
ZERO :: the Fool: blurry[info]annwyd on June 21st, 2005 11:33 am (UTC)
The Lust episode was definitely a mistake. Which is to say--I'm not saying that the anime didn't make mistakes, just that people ought to take into account the circumstances before they start ranting about how Bones destroyed a perfect manga.
kouryoku: he's evil you know[info]kouryoku on June 21st, 2005 01:03 pm (UTC)
The Lust episode was sort of there to trump up Lust as something other than a heartless monster, to give a face to the Homunculus and to generally set the scene for what would eventually be her 'betrayal' of master, through her past and the actions surrounding Scar's death.

A pity they ruined the setup by having her die to the marysue of the series. :`( Really, Lust was one of the saving graces of the anime, away from the military side. A true pity the way her story ended. And surely you enjoyed watching her heaving bosom animated!
Li[info]trelali on June 21st, 2005 01:28 pm (UTC)
Ah, the glory of the heaving bosom! I really did enjoy the way they fleshed up her character, gave her a history and reasons other than 'sheez hot an has fingernales YAY.' I just thought the placement could have been better - they dropped that episode in right in the middle of the rising climax of the series. Just a moment of 'wtf' as I watched.
sna[info]sna32 on June 21st, 2005 12:57 pm (UTC)
oooh. I've never seen FMA. But it's theme song is my favorite Asian kung-fu gen song (Rewrite! Hell yeah!) Is there anywhere you can find it online? I won't know the difference since I haven't read the manga... *is a heathen*

hope you are well
ZERO :: the Fool: secret[info]annwyd on June 21st, 2005 03:39 pm (UTC)
My secret online stash of it is here. I adore the series despite its flaws and would very much recommend it.
sna: rock star[info]sna32 on June 21st, 2005 06:13 pm (UTC)
oooooOOOOOOOOOO!!!

*hugs annwyd and runs to download*

You rocketh, so very, very muchness!

*bolts off into cyberspace*

ZERO :: the Fool: Fullmetal Alchemist[info]annwyd on June 21st, 2005 06:14 pm (UTC)
Always happy to snare a new addict for one of my fandoms~
The Muse, Amused[info]penmage on February 13th, 2006 03:00 pm (UTC)
Do you still have FMA available to download? I followed a link from a link from [info]kate_nepveu's journal, and found this comment. I have been searching like mad for FMA - I've got the first twelve episodes, or so, and I am desperate for more, especially because I'm overseas for the year, so my US sources are no help to me.
ZERO :: the Fool: Fullmetal Alchemist[info]annwyd on February 13th, 2006 07:18 pm (UTC)
Unfortunately no--it's been a while. Good luck in your searching; the second season, following the first twelve or so episodes, is my favorite part of the anime.
Howdy Cat: thoughtful[info]kotoludi on June 21st, 2005 01:28 pm (UTC)
Honestly I like the anime over the manga. While each has their own charm and faults--the anime moreso--I still liked the characterization in the anime more. Which is weird, since I usually prefer the source over the anime. BUT--it was a good show. A very good show. :( I miss it. T_T
RM: ishiichi[info]zinthos on June 21st, 2005 02:42 pm (UTC)
I think it depends a lot on what you were looking for. I admit to getting into a "zomg Bones you didn't include this this and this from the manga you hors :( :( :(" rut sometimes, but...I still honestly like the manga better. Which is biased because really, I think the manga did a better job focusing on the later developments of the military people. (Such as my pet minor character. See? Bias right there.) And -- really, they did make some mistakes. Trelali up there had a good point with the Lust episode. I also point to the whole military sideplot where they simply...never filled in what happened to Havoc and Armstrong and co. during their half of the coup. Shoddy storywork towards the end. :/ (I swear I'm going to write a fic that fills in that little gap. Sometime.)

But -- hey, if you like the anime over the manga, there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. The anime /does/ shine beautifully at times, especially during the first half. I think they did Hughes absolutely wonderfully in the anime, even better than the manga rendition. Ep 25 totally made me cry whereas Chapter (whatever, can't remember the number offhand) just kinda made me go "...what? He's really gone?" without really tearing me up. And while I still dislike the ending for the most part, there were some sequences in the later eps that were simply awesome. Just comes down to what you like, I guess.

...ha ha, spam. Sorry 'bout that. I figure I'm one of the offenders in this, so...
ZERO :: the Fool: content[info]annwyd on June 21st, 2005 03:38 pm (UTC)
Nah, not you. If you like the manga over the anime, that's one thing; it's just the people who froth and rave over the EVIL that is the anime blah blah blah who make me roll my eyes.
Pat Benware: Fancy[info]friendpersonpat on June 21st, 2005 04:16 pm (UTC)
Speaking of which, I don't even remember when I lost track with the manga. I need to find a good non-torrent source.

help-u meeeee~